Speaking of the excellences of the founder of their sect (Maulwi Ismail Dehlwi), Wahabies write that he used to complete the Holy Quran from Asr until Maghrib salaah, with people hearing the entire Quran in a small space of time. - Arwaah­e- Thalaatha.

Now, we ask the Wahabies: You curse and abuse our Imam Abu Hanifa رضی اللہ تعالٰی عنہ because he used to complete a Holy Quran once every day and once every night during Ramadaan. Your Ismail Dehlwi used to finish one Quran from Asr until Maghrib. Is he also worthy of abuse or not? Is he a sinner and faajir, or is he excused for being your leader? Please answer.

OBJECTIONS AND ANSWERS TO PERFORMING SHABEENA

OBJECTION 1: The Holy Quran states, "Recite the Holy Quran by regulating (TarteeI).”35.11 - Surah Muzammil, Verse 4

It's apparent that if, in every rakaat, 1½ paras are read to complete an entire Quran in one night, the Haaflz would have to read very fast. This necessitates not understanding anything besides 'Ya'iamoon' and 'Ta'iamoon'. It's for this reason that making Shabeena is contrary to the Holy Quran's command.

Answer - There are two replies to this objection,

l. Your founder, Ismail Dehlwi, used to recite the whole Quran from Asr until Maghrib. Was he also guilty of this? Did he commit Haraam or not? Hadrat Dawood علیہ السلام used to recite the entire Zabur Sharif very fast. Hadrat Uthman Ghaniرضی اللہ تعالٰی عنہ , Tameem Daari رضی اللہ تعالٰی عنہ, Abdullah ibn Zubair رضی اللہ تعالٰی عنہ etc, who are senior Sahaaba, used to recite the entire Holy Quran in one rakaat! The Prophet صلی اللہ علیہ وسلم himself would read 2 paras in one rakaat of Tahajjud namaaz and 1 Yz in Salaatul-Khusoof (references for these have already been given). Will your objections be leveled against these personalities as well? If not, why?

2. Allahعزوجل has blessed some people with such fluent reading that even though they read very fast, their reading is still clear. Others don't have this ability, and so when they read, nothing except 'Ya'iamoon' and 'Ta'iamoon' is understood. Shabeena should only be performed with the first type, not with the second. This is the meaning of the ayat. Thus, both its meaning and the practice of performing an extended recitation in one rakaat (as proven by the Holy Prophet صلی اللہ علیہ وسلم and his revered Sahaaba) are also correct.

OBJECTION 2: Hadrat Abdullah ibn Amr رضی اللہ تعالٰی عنہ reports that Rasoolullah said, "Whoever recites the Holy Quran in less than three days won't understand it." 35.12 - Mishkaat, Baabu Tilaawatil-Quran

Thus, because we wouldn't understand the Imam's recitation, Shabeena is absolutely prohibited.

Answer - There are a few replies to this,

1. This Hadith is against you as well. You say that Shabeena of three days is Haraam while this Hadith allows it.

2. Your leader, Maulwi Ismail Dehlwi, used to complete one Quran from Asr until Maghrib. He also falls under this. Clear his name and whatever is your answer will be ours.

3. In this Hadith, Sayyiduna Rasoolullah صلی اللہ علیہ وسلم is referring to the general public. Usually when Huffaaz complete the Quran in one or two days, they are not able to understand it. Those who have the ability to are excluded from this-e.g. Hadrat Uthmanرضی اللہ تعالٰی عنہ and other Sahaaba who would complete the Quran Sharif in one rakaat. This is why Mirqaat and Lam'aat state in the annotation of this Hadith that some Buzurgs used to complete the Quran in one day and night while others would complete eight! In fact, Shaikh Abu Madyun Maghribi رضی اللہ تعالٰی عنہ used to complete 70,000 Quran Sharifs during a single night! Once, he completed a Quran Sharif after kissing the Hajar-e-Aswad and approaching the door of the Holy Kaaba. Those around him heard every single word of it. - Mirqaat, Baabu TiIaawatil-. Quran, Vol. 2, Pg. 216

Mulla Ali Qari رضی اللہ تعالٰی عنہ further states, "The truth is that this command is different in relation to the diversity of people." - Ibid

OBJECTION 3: The ending words of a lengthy Hadith reported by Hadrat Abdullah ibn Amr رضی اللہ تعالٰی عنہ are, "Complete the Quran in one week. Do not exceed this." 35.1-4 _ Muslim, Bukharl

The summary is that Hadrat Abdullah ibn Amr رضی اللہ تعالٰی عنہ requested the Holy Prophet صلی اللہ علیہ وسلم for permission to complete the Quran quickly. He was ordered to first make one khatam in one month.

When he persisted, the Prophet replied, "The Quran shouldn't be completed in less than a week." Thus, Shabeena is prohibited.

Answer - The Prophet's reply to Hadrat Abdullah ibn Amr رضی اللہ تعالٰی عنہ was in relation to his condition. He probably wouldn't have been able to read clearly if he had to finish the Holy Quran in a couple of days. Or, here perpetual recitation is what is being referred to. In other words, if every person began completing the Quran every day, worldly works would be left incomplete. There is no problem in completing the Quran once in 1 ½ days during the entire year. Those Sahaaba who recited the entire Quran in a single rakaat knew this Hadith, so why didn't they abandon this practice?

OBJECTION 4: The Holy Prophet صلی اللہ علیہ وسلم never recited the Quran Sharif within one or two nights. Shabeena is an Innovation and we should save ourselves from these.

Answer - Rasoolullah صلی اللہ علیہ وسلم not reciting the Quran in a couple of nights is due to two reasons,

l. In the initial period of his life, the entire Quean was not revealed. Its revelation was completed just before his demise.

2. The Prophet صلی اللہ علیہ وسلم had mercy on his Ummah. If he continuously practiced Shabeena, it would have become a necessary Sunnah on them. Thus, Shabeena was made by his Sahaaha afterwards. The Prophet صلی اللہ علیہ وسلم didn't always perform Taraweeh either but the Sahaaba did with jarnaat later on.

Remember that Shabeena is the Sunnah of the Sahaaba. Insha-Anah, practicing their Sunnat has the same thawaab of completing the Noble Messenger's صلی اللہ علیہ وسلم. Calling the Sunnah of the Sahaaba "Bad Innovations" and prohibiting it is the misfortune of the Wahabies. We, the Ahle-­Sunnah, don't dare do such things.

OBJECTION 5: The state of Shabeena today is that the Haafiz continues to recite the Holy Quran even though some muqtadis are asleep, yawning or sitting from laziness. This is disrespectful to the Holy Quran and thus the reason why it should be stopped.

Answer - This is an absolutely false accusation. Some people solemnly attend Shabeena to listen to it (standing and listening attentively). Some come merely to see it and remain seated. There is nothing wrong with this. Listening to the Holy Quran is Fardh-e-Kifaaya and so the listening by only some is sufficient.

Hypothetically, even if it is accepted that all Muslims listen to Shabeena in laziness, effort should be made to remove the laziness, not stop the Shabeena. Today, there are many sins committed in weddings, such as dancing, music, fireworks, etc. Please don't prohibit Nikah! Try to stop these incorrect practices. There were idols in the Holy Kaaba during the time of Sayyiduna Rasoolullah صلی اللہ علیہ وسلم. Instead of bringing down the entire construction, he removed the idols when Allahعزوجل ultimately granted him the power to do so. If a dog enters a Musjid, don't destroy the mosque, but take out the dog. If there are lice in your hair, don't set flame to your scalp. It is a very strange practice of Wahabies that instead of removing the ills in ibaadats, they try to prohibit the ibaadat itself. Through this feeble excuse, these people wish to stop all good acts such as Meelad Sharif, Khatam-e-Khwajagaan, etc.

If my Sunni brothers remember my answer, Insha­-Allah, they will be safe from the mischief of the Wahabies.

“وصلی اللہ تعالٰی علی خیر خلقہ و نور عرشہ سیدنا محمد و الہ و صحبہ اجمعین امین برحمتک یا ارحم الراحمین”

Ahmad Yaar Khan Naeemi Ashrafi Badayuni

Patron of Madrassah Ghousia Naeemia, Gujarat, Pakistan